Blackstone Shares Trail Competitors Amid Real Estate Concerns

Blackstone Shares Trail Competitors Amid Real Estate Concerns

Blackstone Group Inc. is facing a challenging year as its shares fall behind those of its private-equity peers, with concerns centered on the performance of a prominent real estate fund and broader economic uncertainties. This development marks a departure from the extended optimism Wall Street previously held regarding the firm’s dominance in private markets.

Analysts Remain Divided

Some analysts support Blackstone’s dominant position and vast property holdings, while others signal concerns. Investors welcome better performance in Blackstone Real Estate Income Trust, a significant real estate fund. Anxiety persists over Breit, a non-public entity, worsened by commercial real estate challenges and high redemption requests.

Blackstone’s property dominance has backers and critics; improved fund performance contrasts Breit’s struggles. Investors cautious, WSJ Digital Subscription said.

Valuation Concerns

Questions regarding the valuation of Blackstone’s real estate assets have also emerged, particularly as the values of publicly traded real estate investment trusts (REITs) have declined. Blackstone reaffirmed its rigorous valuation process, citing $20 billion in asset sales at premiums to net asset value (N.A.V.) since 2022, as reported by The New York Times. Nevertheless, concerns persist among some investors, exerting downward pressure on the stock relative to its competitors.

Mixed Investor Sentiment

Despite some investors’ enduring faith in Blackstone, John Miller of Ariel Investments links its weak performance to real estate worries. Miller praises the management’s adaptability but hints at reevaluating investment at a discounted price.

Market Performance and Analyst Insights

On Wednesday, Blackstone shares fell 1.4%, in contrast to the S&P 500’s marginal movement. Year-to-date, the stock is down 8.5%, while competitors like Apollo Global Management, KKR, Brookfield, and Carlyle Group have seen increases. J.P. Morgan analyst Ken Worthington noted slower first-quarter fundraising and ongoing real estate performance uncertainty as factors dampening enthusiasm for Blackstone’s growth prospects, maintaining a Neutral rating on the stock.

Optimism Amid Caution

Despite challenges, investors remain optimistic about Breit’s long-term prospects. Bank of America’s Craig Siegenthaler, with a Buy rating, highlights its strong track record. Blackstone’s Jon Gray also praises Breit’s resilience in tough real estate markets.

Caution Advised

However, caution persists among analysts, citing ongoing macroeconomic pressures and recommending waiting for more clarity on earnings outlook before considering investment. As Blackstone navigates these challenges, the market watches closely for signs of stability and renewed growth prospects.

Embark on a yearlong journalistic journey with The Wall Street Journal, delivered to your doorstep or office six days a week. Subscribe now for just $318, a 30% discount. Enroll today for unparalleled news coverage and enlightening perspectives. Plus, enjoy a bonus: a 12-month digital access pass, including Market Watch and Barron’s. Stay informed anytime, anywhere.

Sales Support